LOTRO Legendarium: A trip back through LOTRO’s expansions

Now that we’re in the thick of Lord of the Rings Online: Mordor (which I’m still enjoying very much), my mind has taken a turn back to look over 10 years of gameplay updates and expansions.

It’s bizarre to think back to a time when the entirety of the game was merely eight or nine zones crammed up in Eregion. While there’s still plenty of Middle-earth to uncover and explore, the ensuing decade vastly opened up the game world and took us on a journey that spanned from Bag End to Barad-dûr.

It all starts to blur together after a while, particularly after alternative leveling regions were added, the epic story was changed to be more solo accessible, and the studio experimented with different forms of content delivery. I felt like taking a quick trip through the expansions that brought us to where we are today. Because… why not, really?

Mines of Moria: November 2008

LOTRO’s first expansion remains, to this day, one of its most significant. With the popularity of the launch and the excitement over moving into one of the books’ most iconic areas, the dev team knew that they were under the gun to deliver. And deliver they pretty much did.

Players entered into Moria to find one of the largest underground regions ever created for an MMORPG, one that would take them months to fully explore. The expansion didn’t stop there, adding two new classes (the Rune-keeper and Warden), the legendary item system, six more books to the epic story, and dynamic lighting. The level cap was increased from 50 to 60 as well.

While Moria does get a bad rap from players who feel claustrophobic in its depths, I think it’s still a pretty amazing space that showed how much LOTRO was willing to experiment and stretch as the story started to leave Eregion. And that Lothlorien addition at the end of the expansion cycle gave us a beautiful and memorable zone to cap things off.

Siege of Mirkwood: December 2009

I think it’s fair to call Siege of Mirkwood a “half-expansion” if you like. It was much reduced in scope, delivering only a single zone, five more levels, more responsive combat, and an ending to Volume II of the epic. Yet I don’t think it was a terrible addition; Mirkwood is, as I have written, an underappreciated zone, and the skirmish system that came with this expansion is one of LOTRO’s better additions.

This expansion is also where I came back on board with LOTRO after taking a year or two off for other MMOs. In fact, I remember reading about this expansion on Massively-that-was by the then-writer of the LOTRO column. Boy, he sure had a dream job! Wish I could do that!

While 2010 did not see an expansion, it did mark the year that LOTRO transitioned into a hybrid free-to-play model and started numbering the updates from 1 on up.

Rise of Isengard: September 2011

“Isengard bids five.”

After years of pushing eastward on the map, it was finally time to push south and enter The Two Towers. Rise of Isengard was an incredibly odd expansion that strove to set Saruman up as one of the principle threats to Middle-earth. And yet it was mostly focused on Dunland, a region that got very light treatment in the books and was quite removed from the Fellowship’s journey.

As a result, Turbine had freedom to take the story in a different direction and chose to show a more barbaric, tribal landscape that was slowly coming under oppression by the White Hand and the nearby tower of Orthanc. It wasn’t the most amazing expansion, but it did the job in carrying the story forward. Players also could level up to 75 for the first time.

Riders of Rohan: October 2012

If you pressed me for a favorite, I would probably point to Riders of Rohan as the best expansion that LOTRO has produced to date. There was so much to love here as the team took us into the country of Rohan, gave us war-steeds, raised the cap to 85, and brought the threat of Mordor to bear on an entire population.

Turbine really seemed to go all-out with this expansion’s release, churning out live-action webisodes, an amazing soundtrack by Chance Thomas, and some of the best art and landscapes yet. The quests were also quite noteworthy and featured a few tricks we hadn’t seen before. Rohan felt huge and expansive, and if mounted combat was a disappointment, then it was something I could get past in favor of everything else that went right with this pack.

Helm’s Deep: November 2013

If Turbine took its time to do Riders of Rohan right, it appeared to have rushed Helm’s Deep through the development process on the cheap. It wasn’t a terrible expansion, per se, but it did feel tacked-on instead of getting the full resources to make a big splash. Even the soundtrack sounded generic.

The developers banked an awful lot on players loving and replaying the new “big battles” system that came with this expansion, and that’s where Helm’s Deep faltered most of all. The battles were visually impressive but overly long, confusing, and grindy.

On the plus side, the expansion allowed players to advance to level 95 as they adventured through the remainder of Rohan. The Westemnet wonderfully rounded out Rohan as a country and added Underharrow and Paths of the Dead, two incredibly memorable locales.

The phantom Gondor expansion: 2014-2016

After the lackluster rollout and reception of Helm’s Deep, the studio said that it wanted to eschew the expansion model and focus more on regular meaty content rollouts. Thus, the MMO didn’t get any official expansion over the next few years, but it did produce what I’d consider to be a full-fledged expansion in several parts with Gondor.

From Update 14 (July 2014) through Update 19 (October 2016), the team took players on a breathtaking tour of Gondor. During this period, a new class/race was added (the Beorning), six new zones were instituted, the level cap was raised to 105, and the gates of Minas Tirith — LOTRO’s most impressive city to date — were opened. This era also saw the Battle of Pelennor Fields, probably the greatest battle I’ve ever had the privilege of experiencing in an MMO to date.

Mordor: August 2017

If LOTRO was ever going to return to expansions, then Mordor was a perfect moment to do it. Five zones and 10 new levels accompanied the launch of this pack, taking players through the Black Gates and into the country that was the source of so much terror and threat. It took players beyond the quest to destroy the One Ring, seeing what happened after Sauron fell.

Time will tell how robust and worthy this expansion is, but as I said before, it’s been a surprisingly exciting and intriguing trip into the Middle-earth version of hell. If nothing else, it was great to see LOTRO return to form with a major expansion, especially one to mark both the game’s 10th year of operation and the milestone of marching into Mordor.

Every two weeks, the LOTRO Legendarium goes on an adventure (horrid things, those) through the wondrous, terrifying, inspiring, and, well, legendary online world of Middle-earth. Justin has been playing LOTRO since its launch in 2007! If you have a topic for the column, send it to him at justin@massivelyop.com.
SHARE THIS ARTICLE
Code of Conduct | Edit Your Profile | Commenting FAQ | Badge Reclamation | Badge Key

LEAVE A COMMENT

10 Comments on "LOTRO Legendarium: A trip back through LOTRO’s expansions"

Subscribe to:
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most liked
Reader
Alex Malone

For me, each expansion just made the game worse and worse until I quit:

* Moria – awesome design to the place in terms of aesthetics, could have been a bit more maze-like but I understand the limitations. The Warden and Runekeeper were good editions too. However, radiance halved the size of the endgame community by changing the dynamic from skill-based to gear-based. By the end, it was better as it had a full raid and Lothlorien, but to begin with the experience was not very good.

* Mirkwood – otherwise known as the beginning of the end. The zones sucked – no longer was this an open world game to be explored and loved, but a generic patchwork quest-hub based grinder. Only one group dungeon and one raid to keep us going for 2 years. Skirmishes sucked – once the initial novelty wore off, they were just simplistic mob grinders. The only good thing was near the end of this time period, they finally ditched radiance and gave us a proper raid, restoring some of the endgame community.

* Rise of Isenguard – this returned us to decent, open world questing and whilst still focused around quest-hubs, the zone design was at least consistent and flowed together well. Unfortunately, it was quite bland for the most part, but at least Isenguard itself was pretty awesome. Again, lacking in endgame content, only launched with 1 raid that only had 1 boss. It was an awesome boss, but still, didn’t take long to put it on farm.

At this point, I quit. The increasing focus on easy, solo gameplay, the lack of content at endgame and a complete lack of investment in PvP made it time for me to go. I had friends that stayed with the game (lifetime subs) and they all confirmed that it continued to get worse. Mounted combat sucked by all accounts, then they completely ditched raids/endgame in favour of “big battles”, but yet to speak to someone who enjoyed them. A lot of the mechanics changes they’ve implemented over the years have removed all depth to combat and trivialised almost everything.

The only thing I know of that they’ve consistently done well is sticking to the lore and creating engaging stories. Sadly, that alone is not enough to make me want to play, I need the engaging gameplay.

hughmbehavior
Reader
hughmbehavior

Moria got a bad rap?
Did it?
WOW!

Back in the day I remember reading a review calling Moria the greatest MMO expansion *ever*, and my reaction was “hell yeah it is!”

Moria had–possibly to this day–the greatest character class (Warden) & the 100% indisputably best MMO dungeon of all time. Maybe a full-on modern MMO Underdark could rival it. MAYBE.

Moria was FANTASTIC.
Possibly my vision is rose-colored by
a. playing characters well-equipped to get along down there (Loremaster, Warden, Burglar)
and
b. a whole lot of MMO experience.

It wasn’t EASY mind you.
But it was great.

Reader
connor_jones

Hi Justin, very much enjoyed reading your short history of LOTRO. In fact I have been deliberating taking the plunge since the release of the Mordor expansion, and your informative and entertaining read here may have pushed me over the line. Also, I really like what I’ve read about how by all accounts the LOTRO world is very lore-rich and nuanced, and think it was a stroke of writing brilliance that (from what I understand) they have the player indirectly (and sometimes directly?) supporting the Fellowship rather than messing with the lore by making the player part of the Fellowship.

Anyway, three questions. First of all, I know I would be entering the game at a very mature point in its life cycle. Is it going to be a daunting task to complete all the major content in the base game and expansions in a reasonable time frame, say a year or two (assuming I like the game and stick with it)?

Also, can you recommend a beginner’s guide or a “ten things I wish I knew before starting LOTRO”? I found one in my searches but it was rather long winded and over-detailed, and I would much prefer the TLDR version. ;)

And before I forget, any recommendations on servers?

In any event speaking as someone who has put Star Trek Online on indefinite hiatus, became totally disillusioned with SWTOR after their serious wrong turn with KOTFE, and has started to experience signs of burnout with GW2 and Secret World Legends, I’m definitely in the market for a new mmo.

hughmbehavior
Reader
hughmbehavior

It’s free to try.
You’re already playing right?
If not, why not?

I haven’t played in a few years, but as far as I know there’s really only one problem with LOTRO: the artifact weapon system (legendary?) It’s not bad to *get* into, but it’s a bitch to get *back* into. so once you start playing, don’t stop.

Also, don’t fool yourself. This ain’t no “free to play” MMO. You’ll be spending $15 a month one way or another more or less…. unless you love grinding like a South Korean teenager. Assuming you mostly play solo in other MMO’s, it’s worth it. I can’t speak to the group content very well except to say it was good but limited in my day. Definitely not a “raider’s” game.

You’ll be fine going through the game in a year if you pay for it.
Worth it 100% for the “solo” MMO player with some money.
Worth it 500% for the Tolkien fan MMO player (college profs take their Tolkien classes through it)
Worth it 200% for a poor grinder kid.
Borderline for a poor non-grinder.

Oh, and quit stalking the Tildeer (TLDR.)
This ain’t no Tildeer game.
You’re gonna spend some time on the interwebs.
Second screen very handy.

1 last thing: for catchup, pick a solo-friendly (Moria-friendly) character. In my day that would be Burglar, Loremaster, Warden. Ask around now. All high-skill, but you seem to have the resume for it.

Reader
starbuck1771

Mordor is fun and takes the difficulty up a notch.

Spoiler
Looks like we are going after the other rings now.

Reader
Kickstarter Donor
Patreon Donor
Loyal Patron
Ashfyn Ninegold

Thanks for the trip down Memory Lane. Dunland runs a close second to Enedwaith as being my most disliked zone. I think these two zones represent LOTRO’s transition from an “open” questing scheme to a closed quest chain. You only can progress along the chain and are only offered quests as you do. This was a change from MoM and SoA’s open questing, where quests were available if you were the right level and rarely had a long pre-req chain that if broken completely screwed you up.

Now, of course, all quests are in a quest chain and everyone is used to being driven along tracks from this quest area to that one.

I also think the Rise of Isengard was a low point in the game for a lot of reasons and it saw the biggest defection of players after the high times of MoM. It just didn’t have the strength to hold people’s interests. Our kin lost 2/3rds of our membership during this period, people that did not come back for RoR. Or, as Gandalf might have said, “Thou shalt not commit boredom!”

wpDiscuz