WoW Factor: Speculating on WoW’s next expansion

    
127
Here we go again, unfortunately.

On August 6th, we now know, we’ll be hearing the name and some details on the next World of Warcraft expansion. What we don’t know is what that expansion will actually contain. The space after this expansion is a blanker space than usual, with lots of possible directions and an absolute dearth of information indicating what direction the story will go in from here.

More to the point, the next expansion is going to be judged pretty harshly simply by virtue of coming immediately after an expansion best described as “maybe worse than Cataclysm.” It’s an uphill battle all around. Now that we know for certain that we will be hearing about the next expansion in a little over a week, let’s look a little bit at what we might be exploring in the next expansion in both story and mechanical terms.

Story – Where do we go? Almost anywhere.

The weird and sad part about Warlords of Draenor is that more so than any previous expansion, it takes place in a box. We could literally go home and have none of what happened on Draenor ever matter again because the whole thing was undertaken in the most asinine way possible.

The games have always had a somewhat lackadaisical approach to maintaining continuity, but Draenor in particular smacks in every way of trying to have time-travel cake without actually thinking about the ramifications. So we’re back in time, but we’re not actually back in time, but things can be different if the developers want to tell a different story or (more likely) just don’t feel like adhering to the existing story, and ultimately none of it matters because as soon as we leave, it’s all nullified. We may as well not have even gone, and if not for the Iron Horde on our doorstep, we wouldn’t have.

The bright side, of course, is that the next expansion can go anywhere. The question is where the developers want it to go, and I’m going to guess the answer to that is “away from the past.”

Just checking this off here,k maybe just being nostalgic for the past isn't helpful when you aren't clear on why people hold on to that nostalgia in the first place?

While we’ve got a long history of killing villains in every WoW expansion, the fact remains that we’ve also picked up several new ones along the way. Azeroth seems to be in a pretty solid place vis-a-vis this expansion, but the fact is that we’ve more or less been completely uninvolved with what’s going on back home the entire time. There are any number of threats that might be coming back around, and quite frankly, I’m hoping that the next expansion features some tie to all of the stuff that’s gone down in this expansion.

Honestly, I’d love to see something that continues to involve the Draenei and almost completely ignores Orcs for the expansion, and there’s an obvious route to go with that – the Burning Legion. We’ve had an expansion focused on them, but it was almost entirely based upon things that were happening in Outland and significantly removed from everywhere else. Let’s see demons coming back around. Let’s see Draenei that have been sleeper agents for the Legion the whole time. Let’s see Velen die and bring Yrel over to lead her people in this reality.

As long as I’m dreaming, let’s also trim up the maps for Azuremyst Isle and Quel’thalas because boy does that stuff ever need an update it’s never going to get.

We’ve had three expansions now warning us that the Legion is coming, we’ve seen tons of stories about it, and we know the threat is out there. It’s fresh in everyone’s mind. So let’s actually go and fight this threat already.

Mechanics and the damage done

When Blizzard adamantly restates its longstanding policy that gameplay trumps story, in the past few years I’ve been left just staring and cocking an eyebrow. If you like anything other than raiding, you’ve gotten neither in recent years; everything has been tilted toward making raiding easier to get into and experience, not actually providing new forms of gameplay beyond the bone thrown in the shape of Mythic dungeons and Timewalking. Put simply, the designers have made a lot of mechanical decisions over the past several years that would be best reversed, and yet simply reversing them is a great way to cause plenty of hurt feelings.

I mean, you could argue that the removal of Justice and Valor was a terrible idea, and you’d be right, but when the currencies were removed and gold was given to everyone by way of compensation? That would be the ship sailing on just saying, “They’re back now; be happy!”

Unfortunately, this is an area in which I don’t have a whole lot of hope, especially because the last developer word on the major problems with the Garrisons started and stopped with Garrisons being “too rewarding.” Not that the Garrisons offered no personal options in a meaningful sense, isolated players, turned the gameplay into a series of chores, or otherwise weakened the game as a whole – no, it was that they offered too many rewards, which in and of itself means that there is apparently some parallel universe in which Garrisons are simply brimming with constant epics for everyone that I am unaware of. Or it means that we’re getting another expansion with Blizzard bumping the decimal point for people allowed to advance their characters past the level cap another space to the left.

Yes, my optimism is up in smoke.

In terms of advancement, I honestly don’t see anything less than another level cap bump, and if it’s going to be another five-level increment, I’ll honestly be surprised. There will, of course, be another complete rewriting of classes and abilities from level 1 onward because the various leveling perks weren’t exactly a huge success and pretty much everyone in the world likes having new abilities rather than minor variants on old standbys.

On the off chance that I’m right and we are smacking face-first into the Burning Legion, if we’re ever going to get a Demon Hunter in the game, this is pretty much the last chance the game has to do that. Whether or not it will is another story, and whether or not it should is a valid question. We are not in urgent need of another class and spec to balance, especially not when the game is already struggling to manage several of its existing specs. But if there was ever a time, it’s now.

I doubt we’ll see that, though. I’m doubtful we’ll see new classes or races. Quite honestly, as much as I’d like to be excited, I’m watching this expansion with a sense of dread. The game has been at the heart of so many ill-conceived decisions over the past few years that there’s an aura of foreboding around it, as if you’re almost begging the game to let you still enjoy playing. That’s not a comfortable place to be.

Making the expansion announcement now is the right decision, though. So I suppose we’ll just see what happens.

Feedback is welcome in the comments below or by mail to eliot@massivelyop.com. Next time around… oh, come on, what do you think I’m going to be discussing? Floral arrangement? Really, it’s pretty obvious.

War never changes, but World of Warcraft does, with a decade of history and a huge footprint in the MMORPG industry. Join Eliot Lefebvre each week for a new installment of WoW Factor as he examines the enormous MMO, how it interacts with the larger world of online gaming, and what’s new in the worlds of Azeroth and Draenor.
newest oldest most liked
Subscribe to:
Xip
Guest
Xip

DrowNoble Mind Flayer

Not lazy – it made sense. What other race would you introduce to X faction, the mantid? That was a joke, btw. 

And if you say Hozen, prepare to get rage-spammed. That would be a shit race.

Xip
Guest
Xip

deekay_zero

So “World of Warcraft: Return of Gamon”? lol

Xip
Guest
Xip

TheGremmel

I agree. Except for the last part though, no matter how hard the boss, the person behind DBM will always create new and correct versions. That’s not a fault of Blizzard really, that’s the addon creator.

greywolfe_joystiq
Guest
greywolfe_joystiq

AttackkonOtaku 
i was completely unimpressed when they sailed that ship.
i loved the idea of the emerald dream.

stazart
Guest
stazart

Also, Cataclysm was the third expansion in 5-6 years and it was a soft reset of the world.  Its been 3 expansions and about 5-6 years since then.  I think we’re due another reset on the world, just this time it’ll be a more significant overhaul than it was then.

stazart
Guest
stazart

My theory on the next expansion:

Lore reboot.
No more subscription.
Game reboot with bridge back to the old game.

Please hear me out before you dismiss these somewhat admittedly far-fetched ideas.

I think the next expansion has been in the works since Cataclysm.  I think Pandaria and, more importantly, Warlords, have been a means to get the story to this moment.  We are on the verge of a potential reset of the timeline in Azeroth.

I also think we are looking at a full game reboot.  The game is long in the tooth.  The opportunity to acquire new players is becoming less and less likely.  Even selling level 90s just isn’t going to cut it.  There’s too much history here for new players to be able to get their arms around.  And, with Blizzard’s legions of Hearthstone and HotS players, there’s a whole new batch and generation of players that have never experienced WoW.

Also, I think its a big problem for the game to have already eaten through all the best and established lore of the world.  Arthas/Lich King, Death Wing, even the wars after the initial invasion into Azeroth.  All these key moments that define the world are so far in the past, they have no real bearing.  I think this is going to be revisited and new and better ways.

The biggest hurdle, the sub fee, I think will go away.  And I think the garrison feature is the key to that being possible.  Blizzard is making a killing off of Hearthstone and HotS and they’ve proven they know how to do F2P games.  I think WoW with an expanded mount/cosmetic/gold shop as well as a whole selection of cosmetic and quality of life offerings for your garrison could make Blizzard a killing.  I think if garrisons come default in orc/human flavors, players would be willing to fork out cash for a gnome/dwarf/undead/tauren/etc skin.  And that price could be quite high.

I also think the garrison is the key to rebooting the game.  Legacy players with literally thousands of hours into old toons could get burned by a reboot.  New players need to have a sense of a legitimate reboot to not feel like they are still at a disadvantage.  So, I think your old toons becoming something like a war council in your garrison, giving your new characters marginal quality of life or cosmetic bonuses would help bridge the gap.  And, if they kept the old timeline world available, new players could venture back and explore literally hundreds of hours of content to get those bonuses themselves.  Just imagine your old druid becoming the class trainer for your new druid; maybe even giving your new character a variation on spell effects or something to help set him apart.

I think the garrison could be launching platform for this whole thing.  I don’t think it really fits right now in the game as an elegant feature in and of itself, but it does make sense if its the foundation for big changes to come.

Additionally, we are getting a movie that will reintroduce characters long dead in the game to a whole new audience.  We are getting an announcement of the expansion this week.  I think closed beta will hit at blizzcon, open beta late winter, and a release in the summer to coordinate with the movie.  And I think the game will put players in the same time window of the movie.  Its a big opportunity and one I don’t think Blizzard wants to miss.

So, I think a brand new 1-60 experience with a more fleshed out and monetized garrison feature with a bridge back to legacy content with no sub slated to release around the time of the movie is what we may be seeing.

BrotherMaynard
Guest
BrotherMaynard

Curse of Gul’dan? The battle continues…

amkosh
Guest
amkosh

Thank you for reminding me why I won’t buy the next WoW expansion. Garrisons too rewarding?  In whatever world the WoW’s devs are in I guess.  And that world is not the world where they get one freakin penny from me.  

And for the record, I think the expansion will be the emerald dream: 

– They’ll be able to turn it out fast.
– The amount of actual content will be around what 3.3 was.  
– They’ll charge 49.95 for it.

chosenxeno
Guest
chosenxeno

This game died with Arthas. No seriously, it did.

DrowNoble
Guest
DrowNoble

fangGWJ I agree new class (or classes) are a must.  You have a game that has approx 7 million subscriptions, about 1000 people on the WoW team and in 11 years they could only come up with two new classes?  I’m sorry but recycling classes in BC was not adding a new class.  Recycling them again in Cataclysm (gnome priests, tauren pallies, etc) was not adding new classes.