PAX Prime 2015: Don’t hate me because I don’t like Gigantic

    
38

If you’ve not heard of the game Gigantic, then I’m going to have to ask where you’ve been because Motiga‘s cross between a MOBA and third-person shooter has been everywhere. Its presence at PAX Prime was impossible to miss. The lines to play this game were nearly stacked on top of each other. Clearly, the world is hyped-up and in love with this game. So I had to see what the excitement was about, and Motiga offered me a chance to play the game with a group of other games journalists and a handful of developers. So that’s exactly what I did.

Everyone on this site knows the games that I cover, and they are all solidly MMOs. But what they might not know is that I also like third-person shooters. I’m a fan of Team Fortress 2 and SMITE, but I dislike League of Legends. My primary reason for disliking LoL has nothing to do with the objectives or community; I highly dislike the control scheme, which is why SMITE is OK for me. But even after playing Gigantic next to some very enthusiastic developers, I can’t say that I’m a fan.

gigantic-pax-2015-01

The object of Gigantic isn’t too hard to grasp. Your job is to take out the other team’s guardian, a five-story creature that has summoned you to fight for it against another guardian. Ultimately, you want the guardians to clash against each other in a battle to the death. There are things you can do to help get to this point: Killing enemies gives your guardian power, and you can wound an enemy guardian when its heart is exposed, which happens after a rampage.

Art direction

The art for the concept art for the game is gorgeous, but at this point the actual game itself lacks the same depth. Like many games with similar highly stylized art, Gigantic falls into the trap of not providing a good sense of visual depth. The lack of right angles or familiar shapes makes the arena hard to read sometimes. This can be overcome with good depth-of-field focus, but at this point it’s not noticeable in the game. It might also be that depth-of-field might be a bad idea because you do need to see the battleground at a far distance, and too much blur would make things more difficult to read.

The heroes

gigantic-pax-2015-02Narturally, the developers are highly enthusiastic about the game, and you can tell that there is genuine love for their creation. That’s one of the reasons it’s very hard for me to dislike this game. I even had a couple of developers over my shoulder giving me instructions on what I should and shouldn’t do during my two matches. Both would describe the character on the screen as an actual person. Saying things like, “Uncle Sven loves to toss a couple of bombs into the fray then run out” or “HK will plant himself on the edge of the battlefield and just mow people down.”

I enjoyed having the developers’ instruction. I don’t think that I would have had a good grasp of the game if they weren’t there, but then having a developer over my shoulder might have ultimately been to the game’s detriment. As I said, they were wonderful instructors, but if I had to have the developer over my shoulder like that, how intuitive is the game in the first place?

The canyon arena

I’d like to talk about the canyon map itself. It was easy to navigate. I was happy about that. You could clearly tell where the good snipe points were, and you could travel from one point to the next easily enough. But without the minimap, there was no way for me to even tell what was happening where. It felt like a tunnel most of the time, and even though the guardians were literally five stories high, it was difficult to tell where they were and what they were doing without looking at the mini-map.

Rounding out my impressions

I really dislike speaking negatively about a game that developers clearly loved making, but the game is just not for me, despite my liking other games with similar feelings. Although the controls where extremely smooth and easy to grasp, the gameplay wasn’t as engaging as another true MOBAs like SMITE or LoL. The characters seemed to have personality, but not nearly to the level of the TF2 characters. I felt little connection to the character I was playing nor the guardian I was defending. Perhaps the game deserves another visit because so many people enjoy it, but as of right now, I wasn’t nearly as impressed as everyone else around me seemed to be.

Massively Overpowered is on the ground in Seattle for PAX Prime 2015, bringing you expert MMO coverage from NCsoft, Trion, PWE, and everything else on display at the latest Penny Arcade Expo!
newest oldest most liked
Subscribe to:
SwobyJ
Guest
SwobyJ

IMO these graphics will be damn popular until the possible 2020s standard of having hardware capable of a better degree of photorealism without sacrificing performance. For now, we can get great 3D performance!…. as long as its cartoony. I really think its a matter of time.

blaaznar
Guest
blaaznar

I wouldn’t call it a MOBA for the same I wouldn’t call Team Fortress a MOBA.

Sorenthaz
Guest
Sorenthaz

If it plays anything similar to Monday Night Combat, I’ll probably be easily hooked into it.  If not, I’ll still give it a try anyway to see I guess.

DPandaren
Guest
DPandaren

Looks too pretty to be real. I feel like TF2 had the bonus with characters because they released a video short on the Heavy before gameplay. Here they just drop gameplay.

DPandaren
Guest
DPandaren

PurpleCopper Those are two very different games though. A better comparison would probably be between Super Monday Night Combat to Gigantic rather then Team Fortress 2.

wontgrowup
Guest
wontgrowup

Shaddoe wontgrowup Mind Flayer ThatLanteshGuy

Hells yes. The game has a great art department. I am excited to get a chance to get into the beta one of these days. 

Devon Cady Lee is the dude I follow:
http://gorrem.deviantart.com/gallery/

http://gorrem.tumblr.com/

He has worked on quite a few games. I came across his work on LOTRO but he also does Dune concept fanart that is just great. If they ever try to do another Dune related anything, they get this guy attached to it.

Denngar
Guest
Denngar

Don’t hate you at all, Larry. You laid out your opinions and can see the product quite clearly, just different tastes. I liked Gigantic when I tried it, but will admit I also didn’t feel any attachment to the guardian, and it is more of a lobby feel (I kind of like mobas when they’ve got that feeling; investing in a character that isn’t mine is something difficult for me to accept these days, so for lobby games, I’m fine with something that’s got personality but I don’t need to invest in too heavily).

Crow God
Guest
Crow God

Truthfully at this stage of development is probably the best time to talk negative about the game. There is still time for them to make drastic changes.

Voxel
Guest
Voxel

SOLIDAge Voxel Ah, I see. I had a friend who linked me to this, I didn’t find it on my own. He expressed it to me as a review site, so it’s a good to see that you guys understand. Sorry for my misguided post! D:

SOLIDAge
Guest
SOLIDAge

Voxel It’s posted under the title of “PAX 2015” meaning it’s a preview of something that was demoed for him.  He mentioned that a few times…I don’t think anyone who reads this site sees this as a “Review”