Leaderboard: What’s the ideal way for an MMO studio to handle toxicity?
MOP reader BulletTeeth pointed us to a piece on The Verge this week about an incident in online shooter Battalion 1944. A highly placed e-sports team member, SUSPC7, apparently went off on Discord about the studio’s slow rollout of skins meant as prizes, trollishly threatening to shoot up the studio. It got back to the devs, who decided to “teach [him] a lesson about comedy” by proposing to reskin his weapon, not with his earned prize but with a hand-drawn penis icon. Yeah, they pranked him.
“I thought you were kind of being a dick,” the studio rep tweeted, going on to tell the player he wanted him to become an “ambassador” for the game.
As The Verge writes, it’s an unusual tactic for a game studio to take against a toxic player in this day and age. While it might be nice to think that studio have the time and money and resources to hand-hold every lost boy and talk him down to being an ally, it’s not particularly realistic, and it creates a perverse incentive system whereby toxic players mop up studio attention that ought to go to non-toxic players.
I thought it would be interesting to reflect on what we think studios ought to do when disciplining players. Does this sort of reverse-prank actually work, or would it be better for companies to just boot the problem children and move on?
Leaderboard: What's the ideal way for an MMO studio to handle toxicity?
- Ban silently. Don't broadcast it. Ban and move on. (22%, 49 Votes)
- Handle with kid gloves. Try to turn toxics into upstanding community members. (2%, 4 Votes)
- Discipline, but tell the community about generic banwaves (etc.) to deter future offenders. (16%, 34 Votes)
- Discipline and tell the community about specific actions/people/incidents to deter future offenders. (15%, 33 Votes)
- Full-on name and shame. Drag 'em. (10%, 22 Votes)
- Find a way to involve the community in judging/sentencing. (3%, 6 Votes)
- Provide in-game incentives and rewards to those who somehow manage to get through a video game match without devolving into asshattery. (11%, 25 Votes)
- Let the toxic people play, but only with each other. (11%, 23 Votes)
- Do nothing. Let toxicity sort itself out or not. (6%, 12 Votes)
- Something else (tell us in the comments!) (3%, 7 Votes)
- No response / view tally. (1%, 3 Votes)
Total Voters: 148