Desert Oasis: Comparing Black Desert and Blade & Soul’s design philosophies

    
13
Wake-up bomb.

One of my favorite MMO stories is how I got into Black Desert in the first place. It was right after I tried out Final Fantasy XIV’s Eureka. I was excited for the game mode but was disappointed when I finally had a chance to play. I gave it for about three days, but I wasn’t a huge fan of partying up and grinding the boss monsters for hours. (It actually looks like our FFXIV columnist Eliot even agreed with that sentiment.) Despite my disappointment, I soon realized this kind of grind was missing in my life, so I started looking.

Since I already played “the big four,” I wanted a change of pace, so I looked eastward: the domain of Blade & Soul, TERA, Black Desert, and ArcheAge. I initially settled on Blade & Soul and Black Desert, but in the end my time (and money) went to Black Desert for three reasons: I wanted to be a dark knight, it had the nicer engine, and it was a sandbox, a genre I never really tried.

I was in good company too. People often ask which of these two games is most worthy their time, given that they’re among the larger and newer and shinier Korean imports. So what better opportunity than today to consider a deep, holistic, comparison between the two games? I plan on making this a two-part series. For today, we’ll just cover the different design philosophies. And as with my criticism of Black Desert’s RNG system, I’m not going to give a “winner” per se, but I’ll recommend the type of player that might like this particular component.

In our team’s last Overthinking article, I alluded to the esoteric nature of these games. Only a certain kind of player will play grind-centric titles. But if you’re the type of player that wants a change of pace from “the big four,” they’re great options. I’m also going to take several liberties: If you’re seriously considering picking between these games, I’m assuming you know at least a little of what you’re getting yourself into. Whichever game you choose, be ready to grind, spend money for a form of progress, and endure lots of randomness.

Black Desert’s design philosophy

This game is a sandbox. There are very few instanced areas in this game, and this game does not focus on merely grinding dungeons over and over again. Players earn their levels and money from grinding mobs, daily quests, and daily experience boosts. Players go to their favorite grind spot and farm. New content usually comes in the form of more grind spots and regions rather than a set of new dungeons. The dungeons Pearl Abyss does include are usually public dungeons too, but they’re more like underground grind spots more than anything.

The game designs everything around this form of grinding, with biweekly events usually having some form of “kill monsters for this special item” component. There’s open PvP, of course, and players are either expected to fight over the spot or move to another server. I went into detail on how servers worked in my last article, but the short version is that moving servers in this game is an easy process. You can switch every 15 minutes, and there are a lot of shards of the gameworld, so those who don’t want to PvP can at least leave.

A central tenet to this game’s design is the hope that you’ll never be logging out of the darn thing. There are myriad jobs that can be done away from the keyboard. I’ve previously covered BDO’s fishing system, but there’s also setting up the worker empire, crafting, building boats, and horse training. Heck, people can even grind levels without actually being in front of the game.

Black Desert is probably best known for its graphics, so players looking for a truly pretty game should give this game a try. In a nod to western aesthetics, the game has really made it a point to show off how shiny armor can get with last year’s Remastered patch. Major cities have a distinct European look, and those who enjoyed an eastern interpretation of the west (akin to Dark Souls) will enjoy the setting.

Blade & Soul’s design philosophy

In contrast, Blade & Soul employs the distinct wuxia style. For those not in the know, the wuxia period is to China what the medieval time period is to Europe. It’s essentially their fantasy genre. This game is so colorful; animations create a water-like smoothness to character movements. This was much more unfamiliar territory for me personally – not at all a bad thing! – and those looking for something that isn’t in a stereotypical western fantasy setting will enjoy the feel and look of this.

Insofar as how it’s structured, B&S has much more in common with a themepark like World of Warcraft than with BDO, but it’s not exactly the same. There are instanced dungeons, but they’re nowhere near as long; in fact, some of the early dungeons I’ve been to are pretty short. They’re only about two or three rooms big, so people might even think it’s a miniature story instance. The dungeons are much more like FFXIV’s Heavensward raids with a small group of trash and a major boss battle in the end. This game does have an interesting tower mode too that I wish Black Desert had. (I’ll go into this in depth in the next article.) I haven’t personally played much of this mode, but it’s basically a tower for one-on-one boss battles.

Players also need to be aware that there are two control schemes for this game. The first is the quintessential action combat mode, where the game controls like a third-person action game. The second is classic mode, which plays like WoW with modifications to accommodate for the action combat. This is a big thing for me since I play better this way; as a dedicated tank player, I like keeping my eyes open to changes in the battlefield.

Overall, I’d say that Blade & Soul feels much more familiar to the traditional MMO player than Black Desert. This game is a themepark MMO with the trinity. The tank, damage dealer, and healer roles are present. [Edit: it turns out while there is a tank and dps role, there are no dedicated healers.– Thanks Jon-Enee!] Bosses have mechanics, so tells have to be dodged, mechanics must be handled, and DPS checks must be met. Black Desert is much lighter on these types of mechanics, so if you like tough, well-choreographed boss fights, go for B&S. That’s why I’d say that Blade & Soul is more for those who still want a familiar experience in a different setting.

The design philosophy might be enough for some players to make a decision, but there’s still so much more to cover! Join me in my next article where I’ll analyze the combat system of each game and what they do with it! Also please let me know in the comments what you’d like me to look into for comparison’s sake – or if you want me to compare Black Desert with another game!

The Great Valencian Black Desert is a dangerous place, but thankfully there’s always a chance for respite. Join Massively OP’s Carlo Lacsina every other week for just that in Desert Oasis, our Black Desert column! And don’t worry; he promises he won’t PK you. Got questions or comments? Please don’t hesitate to send a message!
newest oldest most liked
Subscribe to:
Reader
Loyal Patron
Patreon Donor
imayb1

I feel as if this article is misnamed. You haven’t really spelled out studios’ design philosophies; you have given a brief comparision and contrast here.

In my personal opinion, I think you lean too heavily on experience with other games to review new things. Saying that a game is “like WoW” (or “like FF#”) is not very helpful to understanding what you meant- particularly when I haven’t played that game and never will. Please attempt to explain yourself more independently in the future. Thanks.

Reader
Jon-Enee Merriex

I’m going to join the chorus here, having played both games to and through their current endgames, this doesn’t sound like someone who has played or understands these games.

Putting aside that side by side comparisons by people with stated biases are bad, there are clear facts here that are wrong.

1. B&S does not have the Trinity. There are no healers in the game. Several different classes can be more tanky than others but ultimately the focus of combat is unleashing as much damage and activating as many party ability chains as possible while avoiding taking damage. If you are damaged you usually have a skill to heal you for some amount on a long cooldown or you have potions which are also on a long cooldown.

2. Since when did lack of scripted dungeons mean a game was a sandbox? While I’ll agree comparatively BDO has more sandboxy elements than B&S, that hardly makes it a sandbox. There are literally quest hubs in that game just like any other theme park game.

3. B&S is so dynamically different than WoW it’s not even funny. Just the control layout (which I don’t think you can adjust) is vastly different. If you played WoW and came to B&S it would be incredibly jarring. BDO on the other hand has a lot of similarities to WoW. If WoW had a sequel, it would look a lot like BDO.

Reader
Shadex De'Marr

I passed on BDO the moment they wanted me to put every one of my characters into the same family name. SWtoR tried the same dumb idea. Sorry but the stories are not all about families and not everyone is related. We didn’t watch the epic tale of how the Empire was defeated by Luke Skywalker, Han Skywalker, Chewbacca Skywalker, and Yoda Skywalker.

I play a lot of alts and none of them are related. I get that they want to track griefers and associate bad behavior to evil people but forced family names is not the way to do it. Aside from that the cash shop mentality as others have mentioned is just WAY too over the top.

Most eastern MMOs are basically Barbie Online with exaggerated body types and skimpy outfits. I chalk that up to a cultural difference more than much else. We have to remember that many parts of the world do not have the hang ups with have with sexuality.

Reader
Kickstarter Donor
Vunak

Sorry to say but even though I am a fan of BDO. It is NOT a sandbox. Sandbox MMOs would be Darkfall, Mortal Online, the deceased EQ: Next, Wurm Online etc.

BDO is an Open World game for sure. But a sandbox it is not. ArcheAge is more of a sandbox than BDO and it was considered a Sandpark.

Absolutely nothing in BDO’s world changes due to the players it is all static except for the logo that is on the flags in the Cities and Nodes.

Reader
Utakata

I’m not going to argue with your assessment of B&S. It’s pretty much spot on. If I can add, I find the game too much on rails…even for this 14 year WoW player. And every zone and it’s dog is instance’d….

But If I could transfer my Lyn Blade Dancer over to BDO, I would certainly give it a try. It sounds like many aspects can be a lot of fun.

Good write up! It got the pigtails at least intrigued. <3

kjempff
Reader
kjempff

I still fail to see how Barbie Doll online is anything but a story driven themepark like WoW, korean style. And at the same time any real difference with B&S, but I guess I judge games by other fundamental concepts… meaning I stamp korean on all of them and put them in the same box.
I just don’t recognice the differences :p

Reader
XSetiX

Both games would be doing far better if they cut back the money grubbing tactics by a good 90%. BDO pumps out new classes to get you to buy weight, inventory, outfits, weapon swap tickets and Blade and Soul puts out new gear to grind out when people stop spending lots of money on the cash grab events.

Both games are good but neither deserve the amount of money they want to take away from the players.

Reader
Eliandal

Excellent write up! I thoroughly enjoyed my 2+ years in BDO. Well worth my initial buy in. In the end, we went different directions ;), but I don’t regret the experience!

Reader
Dankey Kang

BDO is a big mess of a game but I kinda feel the same. Trying all the unique systems like sailing, node and worker management, and just exploring the massive world were great fun and even groundbreaking, for a time. It’s just such a shame there’s no worthwhile PvE content outside of grinding.

BDO could have had the world if they somehow managed to pull off an incredible PvE experience with dungeons and raids etc… Instead they went for forced PvP (which literally nobody likes) and nickel and diming their customers at every opportunity.