Jace Hall denies report about H1Z1’s esports league insolvency, view manipulation, and missing money

    
6

Over the weekend, eyebrows inched up again over ESPN’s report on H1Z1’s esports league, which was “suspended indefinitely” following what sounded like major financial difficulties stemming back months. Since then, more accusations have been leveled by VPesports, which says it’s been following the mess for five months, and some of that’s been rebutted by Jace Hall. So let’s break it down.

The esports-centric site and its sources weave a disturbing tale that insinuates corporate insolvency, excessive spending, and deliberate misrepresentation to investors. “In addition to accounting for the whereabouts of the alleged $27 million associated with the H1Z1 Pro League, issues regarding Facebook’s partnership have also been raised alleging viewer statistic manipulation and the reporting of those statistics to investors involved with Caesar’s Entertainment, where the first split was played,” author Elle Thibeau writes.

There’s also a description of paid audience members at live events, criticism of Jace Hall’s treatment of employees, a mention of still more layoffs at Hall’s associated companies, leadership infighting, partial budget records, and a warning that NantG might be in for it, having invested in the company ventures this past summer.

For his part, Jace Hall responded to the article on a incredibly long Twitter recording last night. “All I can tell you is that I’m not a liar,” Hall says, noting he was not personally contacted about the article. He acknowledges that the game has been on the decline and that financial declines naturally follows that trend; he says the league is still in existence but that the second split was canceled specifically because of the playerbase’s size; he denies that the league is insolvent; he denies the claim about the missing $27M (“I don’t know where that number comes from” – that’s “more than double” what the budget was); he denies the excessive spending claims; he clarifies the difference between investors and sponsors; he denies losing Facebook as a client; he denies buying bots to boost viewership; he sorts out the difference between concurrency and total playerbase; he points out that the author’s description of the corporate lineage is easily debunked with a Google search. He also has a laugh over the idea that he partnered with NantG and purchased the rights to H1Z1 (that did not happen). He does, however, acknowledge that folks in Vegas were brought in to bolster the viewing audience.

Notably, Thibeau speculates that some of the weird Daybreak stuff back in August was related to the supposed Renova sanctions, which Hall vehemently denies; he says there was a necessary investigation at Daybreak at the time, but there were no sanctions on Daybreak, and that indeed Daybreak was the victim of the clickbait press. Worth noting here is that part of Hall’s account of the coverage of the Columbus Nova incident, which we covered extensively since we broke the bombshell itself, isn’t quite accurate: He suggests it was a misunderstanding about Jason Epstein’s employment past, which is a bizarre characterization of Daybreak’s misleading the public about its ownership for three years, which is the only reason MMO players were concerned about sanctions in the first place. But in any case, he seems to be correct about the outcome.

Really, it’s an equally exhaustive line-by-line rebuttal in which Hall comes off as mostly honest and transparent – and it still somehow doesn’t portend a sparkling future for the game’s esports.

Source: VPesports, Twitter. Thanks, Kinya!

6
LEAVE A COMMENT

Please Login to comment
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most liked
Subscribe to:
Reader
cursedseishi

I do hope Jace Hall knows how… hollow his response will ring. Not that I don’t believe him or do believe the article he’s responding to, but…

What honest-to-goodness good news has really come out of Daybreak as a company? Not their games, mind you, since we know the general path they’ll follow, i.e. EQ/EQ2 subsist, H1Z1 fumbles, no one remembers PlanetSide 2 (I forgot, had to edit, that’s for sure) etc. etc.. But as a company. Lay-offs, controversy, a general clustermuck of cow fudge pie and lemonade all over the place…

And not even half a year later, this? Even if it’s a lie and none of this is true, how many people are going to take what Jace says at face value AND believe anyone with ties to Daybreak? Cause I certainly don’t, and that’s coming from someone with all of no major interest in their current selection of titles. Because people already know H1Z1 is not a healthy title, because we’ve seen the game it once was sheared away and left to rot while they poke the bits left trying to find any hints of fatty value. Because for all the love the first two games have, the soured interests from the Nova issue as well as… the entirety of Landmark/EQ3 have likely already started to seep into that singular well of trusty goodwill that is left there. And because, dear lord, it feels like we need a horrible source of issues and drama from every corner of the MMO subscription genre. Bless had its stint as a ‘Buy-to-play’ title in a debatable Early Access, Trion has… well, was… and still kind of is the king on the F2P side… And Daybreak? Well, I guess they’ve been gunning to hit that monthly ‘pay-to-controversy’ side and landed it, while also stealing Bless’s ‘Buy-in’ spot with this now too.

laelgon
Reader
laelgon

Even if it hasn’t fallen apart yet, the writing is on the wall for the end of H1Z1. I’ve played H1Z1 and I’ve played Fortnite. Besides the “Fuck You” that was abandoning the survival game I paid for, their battle royale is terrible compared to Fortnite. BR games aren’t really for me, but the difference in quality is apparent none the less.

Reader
Bruno Brito

Jace, you deserve better. Let this company burn.

Reader
Targeter

I like Jace Hall, but I wish like hell he was attached to a better game/product. Dude is too talented to be wasted on H1Z1 or whatever the hell they’re calling it now.

Reader
Kickstarter Donor
Greaterdivinity

I feel like the H1Z1 esports league has taken Archeage’s place as the endless source of drama, because hot damn does it always seem like there’s some shit going on.

Reader
cursedseishi

Who knows… Maybe there will be a company-exclusive variation of ESports out of this?

‘Streaming Sunday, Sunday, Sunday…! Watch as Major gaming publishers and giants compete for a shot at infamy and public attention as they seek to become the most controversial of controversies, the worst of the worst, the… King of the Heel!’

It certainly feels like we’ve gotten enough companies popping up to start something…