WoW Factor: Flying ruined everything and shouldn’t be removed

    
170
Where do we go?

Allowing flying mounts in World of Warcraft was a terrible mistake that should never have been corrected.

For those not up on their history, here’s the deal: Flying mounts were first added in The Burning Crusade, better known as “the first time Blizzard actually launched a WoW expansion.” At the time, they were pretty darn cool, and while a few people voiced concerns about them, most of the playerbase was focused on the idea that we could freaking fly. That seems legit; I know far too many of my superhero characters were given the ability to fly just because, you know, flying.

Warlords of Draenor does not allow flying mounts right now. It might never allow flying mounts in Draenor. The designers have said that flying mounts were a mistake and probably should never have been added to the game, which I entirely agree with. But I also think we’re at the point that questioning whether or not they were a mistake is beside the point. They’re a mistake that’s been made, and they should have been in WoD at launch, same as several other features.

This is kind of the point when the why of flying stopped mattering even a little bit.See, flying has always been a problem. It was a problem when it was introduced in The Burning Crusade, and it’s a problem now. If you don’t understand why, go do the quests in Outland without the benefit of a flying mount, then do them again with a flying mount. No, really, I’ll wait.

You may have noticed that with a flying mount, your approach to every single quest is basically the same: land as close to the objective as possible, kill/take it, take to the skies, turn it in. Landscape layout, enemy patrols — all of that is completely invalidated by the fact that the rest of the game world is working in two functional dimensions while you’re working in three. If you could loot objects from the sky, you’d never freaking leave, and with good cause: The designers basically handed you a cheat code that allowed you to bypass enemies more effectively than any stealth class ever could. Darn right you aren’t going to go back to being land-based.

You can argue that the stuff you normally have to chew through isn’t all that interesting, but honestly absolutely none of that matters. Whether or not the designers are actually good at designing encounters that force you to run in through the land is irrelevant if you are never, ever going to do so.

Part of the problem is that the game’s flight is very, very simple in its mechanics. You mount up and you are, essentially, swimming through the air. There’s no momentum, no need to get up speed before you take to the air, no delay, and little up there to threaten you. You certainly can’t fall from the sky or have to engage in any sort of elaborate maneuvering to stay airborne, a trick that even Super Mario World realized was necessary. Changing all of that now would require a whole lot of extra coding and work and would fundamentally alter so many mechanics that it’s basically a non-starter from the very concept; flying in WoW is what it is now.

It also creates the weird sensation of making ground mounts totally irrelevant past a certain point. Why ride a Paladin steed when it’s both slower and groundbound? The only reason is if you’re still in a stage of the expansion where you do not yet have access to flying, which means that all of the cool vanity mounts people will actually want to use have to be capable of flight, regardless of how silly or tacked-on that flight feels in the end.

All of this was sort of all right when flight was confined to Outland, but it was never really going to stay there. Bringing flight into the old world was one of those things that seemed to be a question of when, not a question of whether, and here we are, with flight just accepted as a thing that should always be there.

Because it should.

Flight, as it exists in WoW, is a huge problem for design, and yet it should not have been removed at all. It certainly shouldn’t be in this odd half-limbo state, where it may or may not be added back in at some point in the future.

Why? Well, to start with, The Burning Crusade came out back in 2007. That’s a long time ago. World of Warcraft came out in 2004. We have had flying mounts in the game as the default high-level mode of transportation from January 2007 until November 2014, which means that it’s just under eight years in a game that had been running for a decade when Warlords of Draenor launched. Flying has been the default for longer than any other form of mounted travel.

You make this an option and then you wonder why we want to stay in the air.Sure, there were always hoops you had to jump through to get to that sweet flying mount, but the point is that you always could. That was one of the joys of reaching the level cap, something consistent and predictable. No one was particularly annoyed that flying required the level cap in Mists of Pandaria; it was an expected change, the sort of thing that happened in almost every expansion. You stayed on the ground for a while, then you got back to flying.

Quite simply, if the change were going to be made, it should have been made back with Wrath of the Lich King. That was the first expansion after flying, and that was when it could have easily been decided that no, flying wasn’t a definite feature. But even then, it would have been a kind of crap move because no one is ever happy to have his toys taken away. Once the can of worms is opened, you have to start dealing with it, not pretend that you never should have done it without darn good reason.

No, in this case, “never should have done it at all” is not a good reason. There are lots of things that the game never should have done that it did, in fact, do. Flying is one of them. It happened. It’s in the game. Players got used to it. There are players – including me – still annoyed that Azuremyst Isle and Quel’danas don’t allow for flight despite the old world revamp. I’m pretty sure that the reason for that is that the zones are technically far below parts of Outland, which is an entirely different issue and perhaps a good reason to keep it limited, but the point remains that the question is asked.

A consistent issue that many people have pointed out with this expansion is that it wants to turn back the clock, to pretend that things never happened when they did, in fact, happen. We all know they happened; we were there. Flying mounts were a thing, and trying to insist that they were a mistake doesn’t change the fact that they were a mistake that defined 80% of the game’s operation. You can’t just seal that away with a shrug and a statement that it should never have been done. It was done. Deal with it.

I totally agree that flying mounts should never have been put into place, but that ship has sailed so far away you can’t even see it from the docks any longer.

Feedback, like always, is welcome in the comments or via mail to eliot@massivelyop.com. Next time around, let’s talk about the ever-rising level cap and whether future expansions could provide meaningful progression without the growing climb.

War never changes, but World of Warcraft does, with a decade of history and a huge footprint in the MMORPG industry. Join Eliot Lefebvre each week for a new installment of WoW Factor as he examines the enormous MMO, how it interacts with the larger world of online gaming, and what’s new in the worlds of Azeroth and Draenor.
newest oldest most liked
Subscribe to:
ReinisAizsilnieks
Guest
ReinisAizsilnieks

Flying makes the game fun for those who arent interested in boring grindfest, that is NOT HARD AT ALL. Same as vanilla raid grinding 6 months each week do the raid, and still dont get full gear, its NOT HARD AT ALL. Flying made it faster to get past the boring stuff, and get to the interesting part, pvp, rp, raiding.

Techbot Alpha
Guest
Techbot Alpha

neserbohy Or, y’know, put some actual dev time into making mounted and flying combat a thing and then introduce flying enemies that you can fight mid-air? I mean, yeah, I know that’s totally out there and revolutionary and never done bef-

Oh wait, City of Heroes did that years ago, and people are still trying to play catch-up *sigh*

Techbot Alpha
Guest
Techbot Alpha

adamph1974 Ironweakness God no, that thing was clunky as hell.
City of Heroes was made before or at the same time as WoW, and they managed to have flying combat from the get go. It’s possible, maybe if they stopped mucking around with other stuff and trying to make the cash shop more of a thing and actually applied themselves to it they could have mounted and flying combat by now….many years after that particular horse had already bolted.

Techbot Alpha
Guest
Techbot Alpha

Tamanous City of Heroes would like to remind you that it was not only ‘1st Gen’ but also made flying awesome. Enemies could fly, and you could fight in mid-air. Why WoW hasn’t got off it’s overweight backside and made that a thing after so much time is frankly beyond me…

Techbot Alpha
Guest
Techbot Alpha

adamph1974 That’s funny, I felt pretty damn immersed when I first flew to the top of the Nexus in Northrend and, IRL and out loud, went “Oh…wow.” Or when I was flying around Icecrown Glacier going “How damn BIG is this place? How many minions does Arthas have now?! Holy hells…”
I tell you what, I would have missed all of that if I’d been on foot. Instead my thoughts would have been “HOW many ****ing trash mobs do I have to go through, AGAIN?! Thanks for nothing, Devs..”
Seriously, as someone used to City of Heroes, WoW either needs to make mounted and air combat a thing or stop whining and give us back flying. I played hard for my goddamn armoured gryphon, damn you!

adamph1974
Guest
adamph1974

Rumm So numlock and go eat a hotdog. :P

adamph1974
Guest
adamph1974

Ironweakness They could do something like that joust minigame.

adamph1974
Guest
adamph1974

Two words, immersion breaker. For example, RIFT basically took a ton of ideas from wow and gave it a nicer coat of paint but I love the game for no flying mounts. On top of that the ground mounts actually run natural, no feeling like there horses on wheels.

rottenrotny
Guest
rottenrotny

Ah yes. The group fiber definitely had a huge impact on the open world experience. And not for the better in this regard.
If I could change any one thing it would be to get rid of the auto-teleport to the dungeon thing. Keep the group finder, but make it so that you still have to actually travel to the dungeon, use the meeting some and zone in.

Cyroselle
Guest
Cyroselle

rottenrotny I had one Pally name Bluerhino that would stalk me through Icecrown. He’d spy me down below, drop off his mount and bubble up, and kill me over and over and over again, in his full Arena gear. To be fair though, I would stealth-drop on my rogue and take out Alliance DK’s so… yeah, flying didn’t really kill PVP as people said. If anything, being teleported directly into instances was its deathknell.