Massively Overthinking: How much would you pay for an MMO sub in 2021?

    
79

A few weeks back, MMO YouTuber Napyet tweeted that he liked Fallout 76’s private servers but that compared to MMORPGs, the subscription for the game was on the high side. The optional Fallout First sub is around 13 bucks a month, with the base game – which launched almost three years ago – still clocking in at around $40, which does seem high for a title that isn’t a full-fledged MMORPG.

How much should and would you pay for an MMO sub in 2021? And what would you expect to get out of it? What’s your top limit for a monthly fee? Let’s ponder that for this week’s Massively Overthinking.

Andrew Ross (@dengarsw): Man, subs just aren’t what they used to be. I just don’t like the idea of being locked in, especially given the amount of great buy-to-play titles. However, I also don’t like gacha mechanics or feeling nickel-and-dimed. I did initially pay $5 a month for a mobile title that admittedly still wanted lootbox money for entry-level competitive play on top of the sub, but $5 didn’t feel too bad. If I could pay that for an MMO but also have a cash shop for non-competitive boosts and/or cash shop for avatar items/customization, I think I’d go up to $8 a month for a $60 box-priced game with, say, $40 expansions every two years.

However, if we could get monthly updates on a free-to-play game that rivaled Asheron’s Call’s monthly content, I could probably do $15 per month tops, but the cash shop would need to be similar to what I mentioned above.

Andy McAdams: My gut reaction was to say that I would pay a max of $20, but I just checked the inflation between 2004 and today and what was $15 in 2004 is really only about $11 and some change in today’s world (being that a dollar today is only worth about 74% of a dollar in 2004). So while we’ve gotten better at development, and the creation of things like AWS, StackOverflow, and other service-based tools has made it less costly to launch an MMO, we are also paying 25% less, at least in terms of a pure sub, and our expectations are astronomically higher than they were in 2004. It’s something like $20 /month for developers to get the same amount they were at $15/month in 2000 if we just look at straight inflation. If I consider that MMOs are my main form of entertainment, depending on the game I would probably pay between $20-$25 a month, but I would likely downsize my subscriptions. Right now, I maintain active subs to two or three different games at a time. If I were paying $25, I would likely drop that down to one game at that price point.

But for a lot of the games in the wild today, $25 is a hard sell. I think there’s probably only a handful of games that justify that cost – FFXIV probably could, maybe ESO. As much as I love Guild Wars 2, I don’t think it could justify $25 a month for me. WoW, most assuredly not. I guess at that price point I’m expecting a full-on virtual world or metaverse. Themepark or PvP gankbox won’t cut it. It needs to actually realize the potential that MMOs have to be more than murderhobo simulators. If a developer vomits out more of the same like they do today, I personally couldn’t justify the cost.

Ben Griggs (@braxwolf): It does seem a bit egregious to ask for both a purchase cost and a recurring subscription (and likely a cash store on top of both). But I’d go the opposite of Sam. I’ve come to the point that I understand that some kind of predictable monthly revenue is essential to recoup recurring server/data center/development costs. I’d propose getting rid of the up-front cost in favor of subs, instead. Granted, this would remove the ability to capitalize on preorder/early access hype so it probably won’t happen. But in choosing between the two, subs feel like the more reasonable match for the persistent nature of online game to me.

If a game were to be subscription only, The amount I’d be willing to pay for a sub would vary greatly depending on the amount of content/polish in the game. $15 is reasonable for a AAA title with a good deal of content. For Fallout 76, perhaps $9 or so.

Brianna Royce (@nbrianna, blog): I think my answer has to be reined in a bit because I’d pay a whole helluva lot for games I want but don’t exist. I wouldn’t think too hard about $50 a month on Star Wars Galaxies 2, for example. I would also be much more willing to pay quite a bit more than the industry standard for a game that actually properly paid its staff and wasn’t just going to take our extra coin for the executives’ third yacht while claiming they just can’t possibly push out content any faster and won’t you please buy something from the overpriced “microtransaction” cash shop. But for the most part, most MMORPGs aren’t actually offering $15 a month of content, and most of them are funneling so much new content through things like cash shops and battle passes that asking for even more than that for a VIP sub seems absurd in context.

I do think Nap is right that Fallout’s ask is way too high for what it is.

Chris Neal (@wolfyseyes, blog): I feel like about $20 a month is a reasonable price hike for a subscription MMORPG. Maybe even as high as $25 a month, though that’s pushing the envelope for me personally. I recognize that these things are freaking expensive to make and I feel like I can’t rightly support a dev studio (and especially see its workers get a good wage) without something of a price raising.

That said, I also recognize that these numbers would see me trim back how many games I subscribe to, or how long a game would keep me paying. As it stands right now, any games I do sub to are done so with general lack of care for whether I play them a lot or not, and I think a rising monthly cost would very possibly see me be a bit more stringent in that part of my monthly spending budget.

Colin Henry (@ChaosConstant): I don’t like to pay for a subscription for anything. If I do, it needs to be for a game that I already like, that I’m already playing a lot of lately. In other words, subs need to be optional for me to even consider them. I don’t want to be locked in for a month and then realize that my interest in the game was fleeting. That makes it kind of a tough sell, because if I already have access to play the game for free, why would I pay for it?

Things that entice me to subscribe are usually optional quality of life things, like anywhere bank/auction hall access, or something like ESO’s unlimited crafting bag. But the game will have a hard time pulling me in to the point where I want to sub if its F2P is too punishing — like SWTOR’s aggressive money cap, limited auction slots, frustrating gear restrictions, and just downright petty restrictions on things like emotes, displaying titles, and hiding the head slot — so holding commonly expected features hostage and billing them as a subscription “perk” doesn’t fly. I also expect some monthly stipend of cash shop currency. It doesn’t have to be $15 worth like ESO, but I want something. Subscriber-only sales or freebies might help push me over the edge, but aren’t generally enough to make me sub up without some of the above. I don’t generally notice or care about things like subscriber XP or gold rate increases.

I feel I should point out at this point that Guild Wars 2 doesn’t have a subscription, and gives you almost everything on this list for free. Just sayin’.

As for how much, I’m more likely to subscribe to a game that’s around $10/month (I’m currently subbed to LOTRO on their $30, three month plan), but I will pay up to $15 if it’s a game that I know I’m going to be playing a ton. I can’t imagine ever paying above $15, though. If your game has a way to earn subscription time with gold — WoW Tokens and the like — I will be more likely to sub up to chase that for future months, because I know it’s at least possible to get to my preferred state of playing without paying a monthly fee.

Justin Olivetti (@Sypster, blog): If I really really wanted to play a sub-only MMO and had no other options, I could swallow a $15 fee. But I’ll tell you, $10 goes down far more smoothly and is actually a tempting prospect even if I have the option for a free version otherwise.

Sam Kash (@thesamkash): I haven’t changed my mind on the topic of subscriptions at all. To me, they simply have no place in the world anymore. I really don’t think anyone should pay a sub to be honest. There is too little time in the day and too many great games out there for any of them to warrant a monthly access fee.

Now I’m not a completely closed minded person. I’m open to discussion and opinions. Maybe if the model was more akin to Netflix or even Xbox game pass, where you payed monthly for free access to games that’d be compelling. However a lot of these games not only demand a sub to play but also a purchase to get to sub. That just doesn’t fly for me. On top of that, we’re not about taking $3 or $5; often the sub is still $10 or more. Did you know that you can listen to just about every song in the world for $10 a month? But you think your single game is worth that or more? No thanks.

Tyler Edwards (blog): I’m pretty much with Sam on this. I’ve always hated subscriptions, and I don’t mourn their passing.

If I was to be convinced to pay a sub again, it would either have to be a truly special game, or it would need to be a lot cheaper. I might be willing to pay like $2-3 a month for an optional subscription with minor perks. Alternatively a low annual subscription might work for me — I’d probably be willing to pay $20-30 a year for a game I play sporadically. Of course, this would still need to be supplemented with micro-transactions, so it still might not be worth it.

Every week, join the Massively OP staff for Massively Overthinking column, a multi-writer roundtable in which we discuss the MMO industry topics du jour – and then invite you to join the fray in the comments. Overthinking it is literally the whole point. Your turn!
Advertisement

No posts to display

79
LEAVE A COMMENT

Please Login to comment
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most liked
Subscribe to:
MurderHobo
Reader
MurderHobo

If something could deliver on the promise of Star Citizen or EverQuest Next? I’d shell out $50-100 per month and consider it a bargain.

But it’s not about what I would pay. I need a game that a few million other people are willing to shell out $50/month for.

ozarubaba
Reader
ozarubaba

People are willing to pay a hell of a lot more than what they say.

Take Black Desert Online for example, I don’t have the statistics so I can’t prove what I say but if you’ve played that game a descent amount of time you’d know what I mean. Many players spend hundreds of Euros / Dollars in that game and a surprising high amount of this money goes to cosmetics. (surprising because it used to be that function was the priority, not how you looked)

Take Star Citizen, again, I don’t have the stats, but do I really need them?

I’ll confess that I fall within that category of players who will find a monthly sub of 20 bucks to be expensive, but won’t hesitate to spend double that amount for something I want in game.

Reader
Darkedone02

0-15, no more then that. anything higher and I have to make a decision if I want to cut off one of my other subs that I enjoy just to see if game would fit for me or not. I rather play for free at best, or pay a low fee. There not too many mmo’s that I like that make me stick long enough to play, then there is some that I enjoy but get too burn-out of it easily. sometimes I stop playing because there is a lack of content towards the game I’m playing or I feel like I am in an odd state to continue on.

Reader
Loyal Patron
Patreon Donor
Kickstarter Donor
Dean Greenhoe

It’s a matter of perspective.

For reasons unknown my wife does not like subscriptions or games that tie her down to a desk [pc]. But she has no issue dumping $500 on a mount in a free to play Asian grinder on her “mobile” android device.

I can not understand the rational.

Myself, Id easily pay $300 for a good mmo to help defray the development costs and then a $20-$25 subscription for the games maintenance and growth.

Face it, it’s 2021 and everything costs more. MMO’s cost money and if we want them in the future we have to pay for them.

Shawn Fink
Reader
Shawn Fink

I feel I get almost no benefit for my DDO $15 a month (well, probably closer to $12 because I usually go in 3-month buys)… BUT, I do it because I feel if I don’t, they will not have money to feed the hamsters that power the servers. I am guilt buying. It does not spark joy.

Reader
Sarah Cushaway

Then don’t do it. Seriously, if your sub nets you nothing it’s the company’s job to provide you something for that money, not live off your goodwill and guilt.

Reader
soup4000

paying $100/yr in fallout 76 for what’s essentially a single-player experience, is about as insane as paying the game companies to NOT play their games (level boosts)

how much that i’d spend depends on how much fun it is, upwards to $10-15/mo

Reader
Kickstarter Donor
Kayweg

20-25 $
There’d be strings attached though.
No cash shop (including cosmetics), no paid for DLC/expansions, no loot boxes.
In other words, no other monetization than that subscription.
It’s either or.

MilitiaMasterV
Reader
MilitiaMasterV

Lately? Nothing. Most of the games have monetization mechanics that annoy the piss out of me so I would rather play them free without supporting their nonsense.

If it’s something I actually enjoy, that doesn’t have all that stupidity in it, I’ll usually pay for a bulk time package of sub (Or lifer if I’m happy enough and they have it.).

These days, game companies seem to think we’re all made of money and just waiting to hand it all to them, but can’t be arsed to provide you with an experience worth the money…

Reader
Costanius

I would happily pay up to 20$ / month.
I LOVE subscriptions! Subscriptions are the best and most honest payment model for an ongoing MMO-project!
I really don’t like Freemium, Pay-to-win, Cash shops, Payment walls and all that BS that ruined the genre.
A subscription model puts all players at the same level and ingame success is only achieved by playing the game. Thats fair and thats the way games should be!

Buy to play has the problem that the developers would run out of money sooner or later if no or few new players join after release. A subscription would give the developers a constant stream of income and revenue, even if the player numbers stay the same and don’t grow any more. One of the longest still running MMOs of all time, World War II Online (first version released 2001!) has had a subscription model though all the years which kept the game afloat!

Reader
Sarah Cushaway

No more than 15 a month, frankly. More than that and I seriously question better things I could find to entertain myself for 15 a month– like an audible subscription or something. Most games aren’t even -worth- their box prices, let alone forking over more per month to be bored. Until the genre really advances instead of treading water, I won’t even bother with 15 a month :)