First impressions and hands-on with Razer’s left-handed Naga MMO mouse

    
11
First impressions and hands-on with Razer’s left-handed Naga MMO mouse

A little-known fact: I am one of the less than 10% of the world’s population who are left-handed. It’s not always convenient (those chairs with the desk that folds down on the right side were pretty annoying for me to use in school, and writing on chalk/marker boards is a pain because I either erase what I wrote as I go along or I have to write at an awkward angle, making my already bad handwriting even worse), but overall it’s probably one of the most mild disadvantages in life I could hope for. There are a lot of tasks that I’ve simply learned to do with my offhand. And one of them is mousing.

Most companies make mice assuming that their users are right-handed. To be fair, if you want a mouse with a good, ergonomic fit, you have to sculpt it a certain way. Generally, the best thing lefties can hope for are symmetrical mice that can be used the same way in either hand. However, these ambidextrous mice tend not to be as comfortable for long-term use for people who, like me, prefer to palm the mouse. Ambidextrous mice also tend not to have side buttons — even the fairly standard browser forward/back buttons, let alone any special bells and whistles — for fear that users will bump them in the course of normal usage. If you ask about specifically left-handed mice, most companies will tell you that there simply isn’t a large enough market share of people who want to buy one to make such a thing financially sound. Most companies, that is, other than Razer.

Razer proudly touts itself as the only company to be making peripherals specifically aimed at left-handed gamers. However, if you’re an MMO gamer looking for a mouse with 12 keys on the side, like its popular Naga series, your options are to mouse right-handed or try to find a used mouse that was discontinued in 2014. In 2018, Razer ran a Kickstarter to bring back the left-handed Naga, which failed to meet its goal by a fairly wide margin. Then, last year, in this video, Razer announced that it was bringing back the left-handed Naga mouse anyway, despite failing to meet its Kickstarter goal. At the time, the company showcased players who are very strongly left-handed or have a disability affecting their right hand who have relied on this mouse to be able to play their MMOs and other games of choice, even some who even struggled to find a replacement after it was discontinued, pleading with Razer to reissue the hardware. Now, this past International Left-Handers Day, the 2020 Naga Left-Handed Edition has finally been released.

When Razer approached Massively OP about reviewing its new lefty mouse, only two staffers responded that we even were left-handed, about average for a team of our size, and both of us had long ago adapted to using a right-handed mouse. I have always been curious what it would be like to mouse left handed, however, so I volunteered to give it a try. I am happy to disclose, per Massively OP’s ethics policy, that Razer provided me with this mouse free of charge for review purposes, but the company was given no influence over the content of this review.

Let me also say up front, I’ve been using a Logitech G600 since 2013, which is Logitech’s direct competitor to Razer’s Naga. I liked it so much I bought one for my wife, who is also an avid MMO gamer. In all that time, the only trouble we’ve had with them is that in 2015 I dropped one of them and broke the right mouse button. When that happened, I immediately ordered a new one because they make playing MMOs so much more convenient.

The first thing I noticed when unboxing the left-handed Naga was that it has an extremely long, nylon-wrapped cord. I imagine that it’s the standard one it puts on all its products (a righty could just as easily have her PC to the left of her desk I suppose), but it’s certainly nice since my PC is to the right of my dual monitor setup, and I don’t think other mice I have would have reached that far. There’s nothing worse than getting a new peripheral and realizing that you’re either going to have to stretch the cord or buy a USB extender to make it work where you need it.

On plug-in, to my surprise, Windows automatically popped up the Razer Synapse installer, which allows users to customize their colors, button setups, macros, and the like. Most peripherals I buy only get the bare minimum drivers at best, leaving users to hunt down any additional config software that might be out there. That’s either convenient or creepy; I’ll leave that up to you. Razer also wanted to install additional “modules” like Amazon Alexa that don’t seem to pertain to my mousing, which is kind of a turnoff. In the end, I opted to uncheck everything and only install the basic Synapse software to manage key mapping.

I was impressed by the build quality of the mouse. I’ve never owned a Razer mouse, but I’ve heard horror stories from some people, while others swear by the brand. This model seems pretty solid as far as I can tell, though obviously I can’t speak for what might happen two or three years down the road. The buttons all have a satisfying mechanical “clicky” feel to them, even the side buttons. Much more so than my Logitech. The curvature of the mouse feels really good in my palm — not quite as bulky as Logitech, but the difference isn’t huge — and the plastic has a nice matte finish that won’t show fingerprints. The only thing I can say my Logitech has over it is the “fourth” mouse button where the ring finger rests, which I use for my push-to-talk key, but that’s not a big deal for me.

Then came the matter of testing with actual MMOs. I knew left-handed controls were going to be a dilemma, so I started researching how other lefty gamers lay out their keyboards. You see, the standard setup, using the mouse with the right hand and W/A/S/D with the left hand, puts your hands a comfortable, shoulder-width apart, but using the same keyboard layout with the mouse on the left puts your hands awkwardly cramped together. One popular option was to use the arrow keys (which were already mapped to strafe movement in all of the MMOs I tried) or number pad 8/4/5/6 and map the other various commonly-used keys to the keys that surround those keys. Another popular setup is to effectively mirror the entire keyboard, using O/K/L/; keys for movement, J instead of F to interact, etc. Finally, I saw a number of players who said that they didn’t really have a problem using the standard W/A/S/D layout with their right hand, perhaps moving the mouse and keyboard further apart when gaming than they would have otherwise.

I experimented with all of these and ended up liking the numpad option the best. For one thing, almost nothing is bound to the numpad by default, or if it is, it’s not something I use. This way, if my right-handed wife wants to play on my computer, she isn’t stuck trying to figure out my weird setup. Also, it just feels nice using that block of keys; everything’s right there. Plus it’s about the same distance apart as W/A/S/D and my right-handed mouse. My setup for each MMO I tried ended up looking a little different, but in general, it was something like this: 8/4/5/6 for movement, plus for tab target, 0 for jump, 1 for interact, period to mount, and minus to autorun. My biggest problem was with Ctrl and Alt for games that require modifiers for multiple bars. The Naga has two buttons below the scroll wheel that by default dial the sensitivity up and down, which I find more frustrating than useful (maybe if I was an FPS player), so I remapped those to Ctrl and Alt, but the finger gymnastics required is far from ideal. I think I would be better off using a key to flip my main bar to a different page and using those skills that way.

Keyboard setups aren’t the fault of the mouse, but they are an accessibility concern. I found myself more than once wishing I had one of those programmable keypad things that I could just map the standard keys to as I wished. Perhaps Razer will come out with a right-side Tartarus for lefties some day? I won’t hold my breath, since I imagine there’s even smaller demand for those than a left-handed mouse, but I’m sure someone out there would use it!

For most MMOs, I used the standard mapping of the 1 through 12 buttons on the side of the mouse to the number row (including minus and equals), since this is what most MMOs use for their skill bars. I ended up needing to modify that for The Elder Scrolls Online, which uses only the first five numbers in addition to a variety of other keys for combat. Setting up a profile for ESO in the Synapse software was pretty painless, and there is a dedicated button on the bottom of the mouse that cycles through profiles. I could even configure the software to automatically switch to my ESO profile whenever I launch the game, though, in my experience, this was a little buggy and didn’t always work.

It should come as no surprise that using the mouse with my left hand felt clumsy at first. Web browsing and other general computing tasks became fairly natural pretty quickly — I even used it for work at my regular job for a day — but gaming was rough at first. After all, I’m rewriting decades of muscle memory here. What didn’t take much time to relearn was using the 12 side buttons for the number row to activate skills. I’ve been using this on my Logitech for years, and once you get comfortable with that, you will wonder why you ever messed with the number row. I highly recommend this type of mouse to any MMO player, righty of lefty, but it seems especially important for a left-handed setup. After all, in a right-handed setup, it’s easy to stretch from W/A/S/D to hit at least the first five numbers or so, but if you’re using the arrow keys or num pad for movement, you don’t have that luxury without moving your hands.

After some time, though, I got to be just as comfortable using my left-handed mouse as my right-handed mouse. I wouldn’t say more comfortable, but I feel like a much more ambidextrous gamer now. It makes me wonder, if I had started using this mouse as a kid, would I adapt as quickly to a more standard mouse? I suppose I’ll never know, unless somebody has a time machine I can borrow for a quick experiment.

I’m not sure if I personally will continue to use this mouse for my day-to-day gaming. While I became pretty comfortable with it after some time, I don’t think it increases my comfort level enough to be worth all of the hassle of figuring out a non-standard keyboard layout. I do sometimes suffer from wrist strain in my right hand, so I might switch to this for gaming when that is flaring up. I’m thankful that I am in a position where I can choose to game right-handed, and I am so glad to see that those who can greatly benefit from this mouse will be able to obtain one without being forced to pay scalper prices. At nearly $100 USD retail, it’s not the cheapest peripheral you will see, but I’m sure it’s worth every penny for the added accessibility for those who need it.

Massively Overpowered skips scored reviews; they’re outdated in a genre whose games evolve daily. Instead, our veteran reporters immerse themselves in MMOs to present their experiences as hands-on articles, impressions pieces, and previews of games yet to come. First impressions matter, but MMOs change, so why shouldn’t our opinions?

No posts to display

11
LEAVE A COMMENT

Please Login to comment
  Subscribe  
newest oldest most liked
Subscribe to:
Reader
Crowe

I’m a lefty going on 50 now… there’s certain things I simply can’t do with my left hand without a significant amount of retraining. Things like using scissors, mousing, shaking hands (way back when the kids used to do that thing), etc. I’ve been in IT for nearly 30 years so I’m always at a huge disadvantage when trying to shift to a left handed mouse. Maybe if I had had a lefty mouse back when I started, it could have been different. But I’m frequently taking over other people’s desks and/or taking their mouse to show/fix something so I’d end up back on the right handed side pretty quickly.

I empathize on the writing on the board. That truly sucked… what was worse though was the first generation of erasable ink. Sure, you could use the eraser on your pen but the ink smeared so easily on *anything* that when your edge of your hand dragged across mere seconds later, everything was super smeared. Unless you used a weird angle and put pressures/angles unnaturally down on your hand to lift it away, the teacher was sure to call your writing out for being messy. (despite the fact that it was the same teacher who was requiring writing in ink and none of the other students were having that issue) Fun times. I think the kids can just type on their laptops these days. In my day, we had to smear our ink across the paper. Up hill. Both ways.

Reader
Kickstarter Donor
GoldenHornet

I’ve been using a left-handed Naga since 2014 and it’s been in desperate need for replacement for a couple of years. The problem has been no one else makes anything like it.

Razor has a reputation for poor reliability and longevity for a reason. The primary buttons have failed on both my Naga and my left-handed Deathadder. The scroll wheel on my Naga didn’t last much longer. Don’t expect it to function perfectly much beyond the warranty period.

Despite this I have bought a new one, because when it works it’s awesome and makes playing MMOs so much easier. I’m too old to retrain myself to use a mouse right-handed.

Also, as a left-handed gamer I tend to use IJKL for movement, but that usually involves remapping all the game’s keybinds, and some games deal with that better than others.

Reader
Chosenxeno .

Seems like people should just stop being Left-Handed. Imagine being Left-Handed in 2020. SMH..

Reader
Kickstarter Donor
GoldenHornet

I really hope you forgot the /s for this one…

Reader
Kickstarter Donor
Patreon Donor
Loyal Patron
zoward

Colin, thank you for the review. As a southpaw, I switch back and forth between left and right-handed mice all the time, between work and gaming. For a long time, I’ve been using a right-handed mouse for gaming, including a Logitech G600 (which broke after about three years’ heavy use; no hard feelings on that one). Recently, I’ve been trying to mouse exclusively lefty as I’ve found it more accurate (but more wearing on my wrists). I would *LOVE* a left-handed multi-button gaming mouse (and not just for gaming!) so I’m probably the target market for this thing.

Reader
Patreon Donor
Kickstarter Donor
Loyal Patron
agemyth 😩

It’s not always convenient but overall it’s probably one of the most mild disadvantages in life I could hope for.

Okay, but when schools and workplaces provide pairs of scissors that are shaped to cut with only the right hand that should be considered a lesser hate crime. (mostly joking)

Its good this option exists, but I’m too far gone in this world of right hand mouse privileged people. For mousing I am effectively right handed. I’ve gone through my share of Razer and Logitech MMO mice. Couldn’t stand my ~two years of dealing with Razer’s Synapse software, so I try to stick with Logitech. I can get used to the shapes of these mice but I always prefer the classic shape of normal sized Logitech mice. I use a G604 right now and it happens to come with six thumb buttons and that is a happy medium compromise I can make for good shape and “gamer” hotkeys.

Reader
Kickstarter Donor
Patreon Donor
Loyal Patron
zoward

No, the hate crime was my second grade U.S. public school teacher forcing me to try to learn to write with my right hand because “the left hand is the tool of the devil”. Seriously. We did not get along.

Zulika Mi-Nam
Reader
Patreon Donor
Kickstarter Donor
Zulika Mi-Nam

My mom said that when I was a baby anytime I used my left hand for anything she would slap it. Ya – redneck hand of the devil thing too.

Reader
styopa

I’m a lefty too and I have to say, this is one context in which ubiquity far outweighs specificity.

There are a lot of LEFTY products out there now, and the internet has made it easier than ever for us all to get “exactly what suits us” whether that’s jeans that fit or a Moss-Covered Three-Handled Family Gradunza.

There’s a reason some products are standardized.

For example, I work pretty nearly all day at a computer. Then I go home and play on a computer. But I also occasionally travel, and work/play from my laptop. And then the (numerous) times I have to IT support my parents/siblings/children’s computer issues. So I’m constantly switching kb’s and mice all day long.

And you know which one is the worst? My wife’s computer has an ergonomic keyboard and although I’m a 80wpm touch typist, if I have to work on her system more than 2 minutes I’m ready to throw the thing THROUGH THE WINDOW. I can’t imagine how much more annoying it would be to have to muscle-memory cope with a lefty-mouse as my home system and then have to swap back and forth through the day depending on context?

Egad, no thanks. What does it really solve anyway that’s not made worse by the oppositional learning curve?

It’s certainly pretty looking, but TBH I wouldn’t in my faintest ever dreams drop $100 on a “gaming mouse” anyway… but I understand you have to write some sort of copy in exchange for free hardware. :)

Zulika Mi-Nam
Reader
Patreon Donor
Kickstarter Donor
Zulika Mi-Nam

Muscle mem – I started using a right mouse in my left hand in the mid/late 90s to ward off carpel tunnel in my right, just from the long hours of work I was putting in. When I do plug a left mouse in though I have to flip the right/left click in the settings since I used a righty on the left for so long.

I have that orig lefty Naga, but I typically only play ARPGs when I go with left mouse though.

Now I am left at work and right for gaming mostly.

..and ya the G600 is my mainstay too and that 4th button is awesome, but you need a pair of big mitts for that guy to be really comfy.